The Gift of Being Confounded

by | Dec 18, 2025 | Attempts at Humor, Faith-filled Pondering, Featured, Latest and greatest | 6 comments

Have you ever been confounded by how something turned out? Confounded? What does that mean? To be perplexed by situations or people that do not meet your expectations.

That hardly sounds like a gift.

As Christians, we can assume life should be a walk in the park, and if something goes badly, then God must be mad.

Not true, my friend.

Rule # 1: God doesn’t think or act as we do.
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways…For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, my thoughts higher than your thoughts.

Is 55:8-9

Rule # 2: We are God’s children, and as a perfect Father, He offers many opportunities and trials to purify and refine us, so we grow in holiness.
             In this, you rejoice, although now for a little while you may have to suffer through various trials, so that the genuineness of your faith, more precious than gold that is perishable even though tested by fire…

1Pet 6-7

Think about it, as we draw closer to Christmas, pay attention to the Infant Narratives—the opening chapters of Matthew and Luke. Notice that right after the Blessed Virgin Mary gave her fiat to the Angel Gabriel, life got challenging and unpredictable.

But wait, Mary was sinless, and Joseph was “a righteous man…” (Mt 1:19); they were practically perfect humans.  They cooperated with God, so why the adversity?

Reread the rules.

Consider this possibility: Joseph and Mary serve as living witnesses of faithfulness to God in all circumstances.

There is infinite value in the witness of the saints. They show us that God can use our worst predicaments and harshest experiences to gain incredible benefits in this life and the one to come.

Confounding, right!

Let’s go deeper with Joseph and Mary.

Joseph is betrothed to a virgin who becomes pregnant by God. He requires heavenly persuasion to marry her and obediently does so. No time to settle into married life when they are required to travel to Joe’s ancestral home in Bethlehem, about ninety miles away.

Their mode of transportation was not a comfortable flight, but walking or riding a donkey. We complain about coach seats, but can you imagine riding a donkey for a week—while nine months pregnant—only to arrive with no rooms to rent?

A cave with animals looks agreeable after the long trip, and nowhere else to stay. Jesus was born and lay in a manger for a bed. It’s cold and dark, and there’s no local Starbucks to grab some hot cocoa to celebrate the birth. Uninvited guests pop by to see the new king, bringing their bleating sheep. Followed by strange royalty, bearing unusual gifts.

Within a short period of time, Joseph is again visited in a dream by Gabriel, who sends them immediately packing for Egypt in the middle of the night; little Jesus is in danger of being murdered.

Imagine the blackness of the night, the piercing cold, and few provisions. They can’t pop into REI and get extra bedding, run through McDesert’s to grab a happy pouch or stop by Sprout’s for baked Challah.

I’ve been to the Sahara desert at night; it’s an ever-changing landscape, black and cold with all the crawly things that emerge. Joseph and Mary had to navigate the Sinai Desert as they journeyed toward Egypt.

And this was only the first few months of their life together.

Why would God allow this to happen to Mary and Joseph, who were faithful? It can seem unfair and frankly cruel.

A couple of thousand years later, we can look back in time and say, WOW, thank you for showing us what courage looks like in the face of life’s extreme challenges.

Thank you for your unhesitating obedience and trust in God’s plan, which brought forth our Savior in what appears to be the most unlikely of scenarios.

It’s confounding, really!

Everything God does and allows has purpose. Joseph’s obedience was tested regarding Mary, his wife. The Bethlehem trip brought the future Bread of Life into the City of Bread. Where He slept, and animals fed—was a foretaste of the day we too would partake of Him in the Eucharist. The miserable trip to Egypt protected Christ’s life, and God called His Son out of Egypt as He once called His ancestors and us, from the slavery of sin.

Joseph and Mary exemplified what it means to trust and surrender completely to God, even when it appears senseless from our perspective.

And that is the key: perspective.  God sees everything at once, all time and history. We see a pixel of a moment. God has a perspective worthy of entrusting everything. It might look wonky, unnecessary and scary from our angle; however, because His perspective is perfect and the only one that matters, our job as His children is to let go and let God lead us.

If everything had been perfect for Joseph and Mary, we wouldn’t have discovered the more profound hidden meaning. A king who had everything. No stress, unpredictable challenges or hardships. Chariots, servants and caravans with everything the family could ever need or want.  A palace, attendants and nothing we could relate to at all.

It simply would be a fairy tale.

God allows what he allows for a reason. I am stronger for all I’ve suffered, and I have grown tremendously in trusting God.

In those times when it feels like everything is falling apart, look to Jesus, Mother Mary and St. Joseph. Give everything to God. Take the next right step and know that God will never abandon you. He may stretch us further than we ever imagined possible, but in doing so, we are learning a little something about Him and ourselves.

And the confounding thing is, it’s an amazing, unexpected gift.

I’m published! Do you want to learn more about the Blessed Virgin Mary? Why not pick up the book here! This collection of over 30 titles of Our Lady and how she worked in the lives of its authors. I wrote the chapter on Our Lady of Perpetual Help. Every order in December will also receive a 5X7 copy of the original work by artist Thomas Hanchett, of Our Lady of Guadalupe

Thank YOU!
Discover more about the most perfect woman in history

6 Comments

  1. Melissa Murray

    What comes to mind immediately is your story of living in South Korea quickly after getting marriage. No it wasn’t easy, a new marriage, learning each other’s habits, living under Marshall law only to be thrown left and right as the US government demanded. Losing your husband for 2 weeks at a time for missions. You lived through years of moving, struggles, being away from home, and learning to juggle 5 babies. But look now 46 years have passed and through your experiences the amount of “seeds” you’ve planted through your stories are saving marriages. Jesus endured so we could live. You went through your own sacrifices and trials to allow others to learn from you. Beautiful article! Good reminder as we come to our closing week of advent.

  2. Barbara Waterkotte

    Life is confounding……….God’s love isn’t and it’s bigger than anything we can think or imagine! That’s the gift!
    Thank you, Barb, for reminding us about just how we are gifted with God’s never-ending love.
    Merry Christmas! God bless you.

  3. Kevin McHugh

    Barb, when I think about how God gave his only son, knowing everything that would happen to him, it always reminds just how much he loves us all without any condition. This is hard to fathom with the human mind. I think about Abraham obeying God and taking his son to the alter in Moriah to sacrifice, and Abraham obeyed. I struggle thinking about this as I do not think I could honestly do this myself. Thank God he picked Abraham and not me. I am reminded in so many ways how blessed I am and how God does answer prayers and the importance of trusting and surrender. Lord I believe, help my unbelief. Merry Christmas!

  4. Terry

    Very nice perspective on the holy family.

  5. Billy G

    No matter how much I read or the number of sermons and church missions I listen to on YouTube each day, I am so amazed and filled with awe, our God has created everything so wonderfully, he has thought of everything.
    How can anyone convince themselves that He does not understand or cannot relate to my personal struggles.
    During those moments when I start to feel my cross is too much for me, I am reminded again, through this wonderful reminders, such as you have presented here Barb, that I just need to follow the examples, of our Lord, the holy family, and all saints that have gone before us. And of course, ask for their prayers to stay the course.

  6. Kathey

    Such a great column Barb & one that I needed today!! I often wonder why I must suffer so much. As you know, I’m NOT a happy camper about needing ANOTHER back surgery! Jesus miraculously healed my father who was a paraplegic back in 1975. Why can’t he heal me? But the moment I surrendered all of it to Him & said those words “Jesus, if you want it then so do I. Jesus I trust in you.”, then a great sense of peace flowed over me that could only come from God. He never gives us more than we can handle, & I wish He didn’t trust me so much, but He knows that I’m a willing participant in the role of the salvation of souls. I’m actually very, very unworthy of this tremendous grace! But I believe that my constant union with Christ in His Passion & suffering is indeed saving souls. God has a most perfect plan for every one of us. Like you said, we need to just surrender every detail of our lives to God & let Him run the show. Life with Jesus is a great adventure but He never promised us that life would be easy. He promised us that He would give us the grace we need to handle all of the crosses that He allows to come our way. The Holy Family are such powerful witnesses for us to follow & emulate!!